Wednesday, March 24, 2010

Why do teenagers rebel?

Reposting from old Myspace blog.

--------------------------

Fuck authority.

I pray (figuratively, of course) you'll forgive me for using that cliche, but what better way is there to start a teenager's blog? After all, the teenage years are supposed to be our rebellious ones. And the consensus is that it's just a phase we go through, that as we get older we start to grow out of it.

The consensus is, however, wrong. We do not grow out of rebellion. We (or, at least, most of us) are forced out of it. This essay will examine how three primary facets of society utilise their overwhelming influence on teenagers in order to drive revolutionary activity out of their systems. These three facets, namely, schools, the government and parents, play a key role in maintaining society as it is. Whether or not that is a good thing is a matter of opinion.

Schools operate on what is essentially a punishment and reward system. If you obey, keep your head down and turn in assignments by a tidy deadline, you recieve good marks. While these marks are nothing but letters, you are told that they matter. An A-student is better than a B-student. They validate your worth. And as we are young when we join the educational system, we are easily indoctrinated. To the teenager, particularly in their senior years, grades seem important.

If you are disobedient or unruly, you are punished. Fighting will earn you a suspension. Refusal to co-operate and perform the work the school expects you to do ('For your own benefit!') will earn you a detention. Worst of all, perhaps, performing your work to an unsatisfactory standard will shunt you down the academic hierarchy and result in you being deemed inferior to the other students. Teachers won't tell you this; they will, if they are 'good' teachers, attempt to help you, to bring you up to the standard that others have set for you. But at the end of the year, it is the 'gifted and talented' students, forever above you, who will receive the better mark for their achievements.

This 'good and bad' system is so closely aligned with co-operation with the school and the authorities within it, that the idea of the rules being based on anything else is more than a little suspicious. Ask a teacher why you are punished for not handing in your assignments, and keep asking why until you get to the core of it. The work you did not do will not affect anybody else. It will not achieve anything. The act of handing it in will not make you smarter (or at least, the gain will be negligible). When it comes down to the basis of the school's rules, there is only one true foundation: do what the school wishes, or face the consequences.

As any entity would, the school takes measures to protect itself, to survive. Anything that would be counterproductive to the school's health, therefore, is against the rules. If a student decides to wag a class, that is equivalent to the employee of a company not showing up to work one day. Just as the renegade employee loses the firm money, the student's absence from class results in declining grades, for which the school may be blamed. The school minimises risk by demanding that all students are prompt, and enforcing these rules with detentions.

So, too, does the school maintain it's wellbeing, by creating rules against misuse of the computer labs, or wearing the wrong uniform. Infringement of these rules will hurt only the school, which is why at least some, if not all school policies, have their roots in the survival of the educational system. Rebellion and disregard for the rules is punished. Students are tamed the same way you would tame a dog not to bark - with a firm smack on the head each time it occurs. After the treatment has worked, the dog looks unharmed and feels unharmed, but the damage has been done. It has been forced to change. Rebellion has been stamped out.

While the focus of this essay is not to proclaim the necessity of rebellion, I must continue the analogy one step futher; a dog's bark is natural. After humans have domesticated the dog, both parties seem happier. The human is happier, as the dog has stopped doing something which disturbed it. The dog thinks it is happier, because it's owner has stopped hitting it. But the fact remains that it is not allowed to be it's natural self, and maybe the dog would have been happier undomesticated? Who knows? The dog has forgotten what it was like to bark at the moon all night long, and the student, who has now left school, has forgotten what it was like to hate the establishment.

Governments are remarkably similar to schools, except they unabashedly drop the pretence of attempting to teach, and admit right off the bat that they are trying to control. Some may suggest that governments only govern in order to benefit others, but this argument may be safely laughed out of the room. If I were to murder a man, then placing me in jail clearly does not benefit me. In fact, the only possible way a government can attempt to 'benefit' (if it tries at all) is to attempt to benefit everybody. In an act very similar to the one performed by robots in one of Asimov's classics (I would use the name, but it would only conjure up memories of a film that does not do Asimov justice), the government must put in place laws to protect itself, so that it may continue to benefit others.

The above reasoning shows why even if the government truly is benevolent, and seeks to serve, it must assume the same role as the school does, and stop others from bringing it down. Refusing to comply with a police officer will probably result in you spending a night or two behind bars. For a more serious offense, such as obstructing justice, you could face more jail time and a hefty fine. While the subjects they teach you in school certainly don't prepare you for the real world, their legal system does. Governments and schools both protect themselves in the same manner - by punishing you if you don't co-operate.

The rewards a government offers you, however, are much more tangible than a mere letter on a report card. There are the obvious advantages; the government will give you free money if you are unemployed. They will look after you if you are lost overseas. They will investigate for you if you are robbed. And there are the more subtle bonuses to a relationship with the government; rebates, which amount to free goodies for you, government initiatives, and so on.

All of this in exchange for taxes, and compliance with a lengthy list of rules. I very much doubt anybody has ever read the entire literature of Australian law, or even made a very good attempt at it. Besides, reading and comprehension are two very different things. And while a large portion of this literature certainly includes amendments and filler, the actual substance it contains is also staggering. Try making a list of every law you know of. I can almost guarantee you, without having tried it myself, that you would not remember every law before you die. That is the enormity of the legal system.

Continuing the analogy from above, you, as a dog, are given several thousand flaming hoops to jump through. After you jump through a hoop, you are given a dog biscuit. And you must do this for the rest of your life. Now the ethics of the situation are much more clear cut - to require that much effort and obedience from a dog is evil, no matter the reward given. Furthermore, as humans cover almost the entire planet, the only way this dog can escape from his owner is to run away to a place like Antarctica, which is not only unattractive, but probably infeasible.

The dog may not kill the owner, because the owner, like any human, will do the very best in its' power to survive. That is the reason why the government controls riot police and the army. In case anybody or anything tries to destroy it or rebel against it, it will fight back. Even if you are never tear-gassed by a policeman, the knowledge that it would be a possibility if you were to cry foul in the streets serves as a deterrent. Any successful government, must, to a certain degree, rule by fear. If people do not fear it, they may not listen to it, and the seat of all it's power would crumble. If a government is to exist, the establishment of fear is a necessary evil, and it does a very good job at crushing rebellion.

As touched upon briefly above, though, the best way to control a subject is through their mind. If you have read my blogs before, you'll no doubt know that I adore the novel 1984 by George Orwell, and the ending scene seems to agree with my thesis for this paragraph. Winston finally 'realises' that he loves Big Brother, and that is far more potent than any execution could have been. The deadliest tools a state or school may wield, in my opinion, are parents. Complete and utter access to their children, a much larger repetoire of possible punishments (for example, a parent smacking their child is much more acceptable than a policeman doing the same), control over who they talk to and what they do, and most importantly of all... an aura of trust.

A young child trusts their parents as completely as they would trust God himself. Their parents are the earliest authority figures in their lives, and the most significant throughout them. Parents teach their children how to walk, how to read, how to speak, and the child laps it up eagerly, compelled to do so by natural instinct. And the parent, without realising it, teaches their child not to rebel. Firstly against them, but also against schools and once they are more aware still, against the government. The child, far too young to even pronounce indoctrination, yet alone understand it or recognise it, accepts this as well.

It is easy to see how a parent's primary concern is ensuring no rebellion against them ever takes place. The parent lays down the law for the child, and breaching these laws causes the parent to disapprove of the child's behaviour. The punishment need not be severe; the child loves the parent, and even a single reprimand could result in tears, depending on the sensitivity of the child and the severity of the rebuke. Once the groundwork of the relationship is set, the parent moves on to preventing rebellion against schools.

As long as a teacher does not commit some horrible atrocity, a parent will usually side with them over matters involving their child. If a hypothetical child, Robert, is not doing his homework, is the parent more likely to congratulate him, or tell him he is doing the wrong thing? Obviously, the latter is far more likely, and in this manner rebellion against a school is disencouraged. While the parent may begin to side with their child more and more in later years, the supposed alliance is controlled so that open rebellion remains out of the question. In the same way, parents teach their children not to disobey the government. If a child breaks a law, most parents would tell their child they have been naughty and not to do it again. Interestingly, those parents who don't teach their children this, or even foster anti-government acts, would probably have their children taken away from them for negligence; another way the government protects themselves from potential rebellion.

There have been some bold statements made during this essay, as is perhaps inevitable when discussing schools, governments and particularly parents in a negative light. However, there is one exception to the above descriptions of indoctrination and subjugation. The teenage years. After all, the teenage years are supposed to be our rebellious ones. But why is that? If rebellion is a natural phenomenon, born into every human but bred out just as readily, why are humans most rebellious when they enter adolescence?

The theory I put forward is that, as teenagers, our minds are beginning to mature without an overbearing influence from any of the three primary facets of society I have mentioned above. Government is not yet a major controlling factor of our lives; while we must obey laws, they are not so much compelling as they are restricting. The orders tend to be, "don't jump through this hoop", rather than "jump through this one over here". As young adults, we feel as though parents are less important to us than they were before. While their advice is still valuable, we perceive that it is time for us to begin making our own advice, and figure out life for ourselves. And school, while still a rather large factor, is not so daunting once we realise we are taller than the teachers and they are just as human as we.

Because of this lack of control from the three forces above, the teenage mind is able to flourish and blossom, and ignite as though a fuse had been lit. At this time in our lives, most of our minds are as unfettered as they shall ever be, and we recognise schools, governments and parents for what they are; control freaks. The natural tendency is to throw off the shackles that have held us in place for so long, and the natural response from these influences is to fight back just as hard. One human spirit, however, cannot endure forevermore against two parents, a large community of teachers, and an even larger community of bureaucrats. We are broken, and return to our submissive state.

In conclusion, the thesis behind my argument is as follows. Rebellion against higher authority is a part of human nature, as no man or woman instinctively wishes to feel inferior. In order to combat this, certain entities who desire to assume the role of higher authority (in particular, the three social forces of schools, governments and parents) protect themselves against rebellion primarily through punishment and reward systems. The pressure these forces put upon people to submit is fairly constant throughout a person's life, lapsing only during the teenage years, which would help explain why teenagers appear to be so rebellious.

No comments:

Post a Comment